The big debate: which race would you cut from the Cheltenham Festival?
Following news that a race at the Cheltenham Festival will be axed to make way for a Mares' Chase in 2021, three Racing Post writers reveal which race they would like to drop.
Not a proper race
As a die-hard fan of a three day-festival, I'm somewhat spoilt for choice as to which race I'd choose to bin to make way for the proposed Grade 2 Mares' Chase.
Of the races introduced since the switch to four days in 2005, Wednesday's juvenile handicap, understandably, regularly figures near the bottom of the list of contests by betting turnover at the meeting, but at least it's a proper race. On the other hand, the preceding Cross Country Chase isn't. Races on the cross-country course have a novelty value, but the festival doesn't need one.
Steve Mason, Racing Post Ratings
Simply a victory lap
In the last nine renewals of the Mares' Hurdle only once has the favourite gone off odds-against. Far too often the race has proved not to be a championship contest worthy of its place at racing's showpiece event, but simply a victory lap for a far superior mare who's capable of cutting it against the best of the boys.
The Mares' Hurdle deprives racing fans of genuinely exciting clashes. It's scarcely believable Big Buck's and Quevega failed to face each other during their careers, but they did not clash as Quevega was able to mop up easy pickings in the Mares' Hurdle.
Tony McFadden, Reporter
Illogical for novices at intermediate trip to have so many options
If one race has to be dropped to make way it would make a lot of sense for it to be the Close Brothers.
The Grade 1 novice chases at the festival tend to have among the lowest field sizes. While they would not always benefit from an added raft of '25s bar' runners, this year's winner A Plus Tard should have run in a championship race and, now the ceiling rating is 145 rather than 140, his type will only become more common.
There is also a matter of symmetry. The new mares' race will be a 2m4f novices' chase. Should the Close Brothers stay, a novice chaser at the intermediate trip could have the widest range of options at Cheltenham. That seems illogical. With some regret, the Close Brothers must go.
Keith Melrose, Betting Editor
Which race would you scrap at the Cheltenham Festival? Email your views to editor@racingpost.com
Published on 12 August 2019inBritain
Last updated 17:46, 12 August 2019
- Dry forecast means Newmarket ground set to ride marginally quicker on Sunday
- Newmarket: Seven Questions has all the answers after springing 33-1 shock in Palace House Stakes
- 'He'll prove it to the world in the next few weeks - he could be the best I’ve trained' - David Menuisier relishing Sunway Saint-Cloud date
- Champion Stakes hero King Of Steel shows his mettle in preparation for Sandown return
- Leading jumps owners Simon Munir and Isaac Souede appoint Bryony Frost as new retained rider in France
- Dry forecast means Newmarket ground set to ride marginally quicker on Sunday
- Newmarket: Seven Questions has all the answers after springing 33-1 shock in Palace House Stakes
- 'He'll prove it to the world in the next few weeks - he could be the best I’ve trained' - David Menuisier relishing Sunway Saint-Cloud date
- Champion Stakes hero King Of Steel shows his mettle in preparation for Sandown return
- Leading jumps owners Simon Munir and Isaac Souede appoint Bryony Frost as new retained rider in France