Handicapping isn't a justice system, so it's right some non-finishers are raised
In 1934, shortly after his failed attempt to be elected governor of California, American writer Upton Sinclair wrote the now-famous idiom: 'It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it'.
It is a phrase that often springs to mind when issues of handicapping arise in the racing media. The most famous recent example would be the Gigginstown-orchestrated pantomime over Grand National weights, but there are smaller examples sprinkled through everyday racing life. You will not need to read many race previews in the Racing Post to find a trainer or owner bemoaning a handicap mark.
Of course, almost all handicap ratings are subjective to an extent. Automated handicapping is a cause celebre in certain circles, but still comes up short far too often for us to think about removing the human hand anytime soon. And it barely needs spelling out to punters that where there is judgement, there is debate.
Read the full story
Read award-winning journalism from the best writers in racing, with exclusive news, interviews, columns, investigations, stable tours and subscriber-only emails.
Subscribe to unlock
- Racing Post digital newspaper (worth over £100 per month)
- Award-winning journalism from the best writers in racing
- Expert tips from the likes of Tom Segal and Paul Kealy
- Replays and results analysis from all UK and Irish racecourses
- Form study tools including the Pro Card and Horse Tracker
- Extensive archive of statistics covering horses, trainers, jockeys, owners, pedigree and sales data
Already a subscriber?Log in
Published on inComment
Last updated
- We know that times are tight - but racecourses really do need to step up and improve outdated weighing rooms
- The budget has heaped even more trouble on racing - and I fear many trainers will now decide the numbers just don't add up
- Why I think Cheltenham Festival handicaps need to change - JP McManus writes exclusively for the Racing Post
- No-one has ever emerged from the womb wearing a trilby - racing's future survival hangs on pursuing a young audience
- Four score and ten just a number to Peter Harris as July Cup triumph shows there's more to the elderly than medical conditions
- We know that times are tight - but racecourses really do need to step up and improve outdated weighing rooms
- The budget has heaped even more trouble on racing - and I fear many trainers will now decide the numbers just don't add up
- Why I think Cheltenham Festival handicaps need to change - JP McManus writes exclusively for the Racing Post
- No-one has ever emerged from the womb wearing a trilby - racing's future survival hangs on pursuing a young audience
- Four score and ten just a number to Peter Harris as July Cup triumph shows there's more to the elderly than medical conditions