down cross right results icon premium content video video hollow icon audio lifeNews icon-comment tick starFilled betSlip hot icon-liveCommentary refresh spinner arrow-down

Lords' concerns over levy reforms to be examined in parliament

The government's levy reforms are to be discussed in parliament
1 of 1

The second stage of the government's reform of the levy system is to be examined in parliament on Wednesday after a Lords committee expressed concerns about the process.

New sports minister Mims Davies will make her first public comments on racing when she appears before the joint meeting of the House of Lords Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee (DPRRC) and the House of Commons Regulatory Reform Committee.

The government's first stage of levy reform, which extended the funding system to betting operators based overseas, came into force in April 2017 but plans to then divide the Levy Board's collection and distribution duties between the Gambling Commission and a new Racing Authority respectively were delayed 12 months after prime minister Theresa May called a snap general election.

Politicians blast plans for levy replacement system

According to the government the new arrangements will save on administration costs and ensure more funding is available for the British horseracing industry and horse welfare,

The legislative reform order (LRO) – a piece of secondary legislation – which would enact those changes was introduced on October 9.

However, in its initial scrutiny of the draft LRO, the DPRRC expressed concerns about its appropriateness and whether it meets the necessary statutory tests.

As a result, the proposal is subject to a "super-affirmative procedure" by which ministers are required to consider proposals from the regulatory reform committees of both houses before deciding whether to proceed.

DPRRC chairman Lord Blencathra said: "The DPRRC has reported that it has concerns about this piece of legislation and welcomes the opportunity to join with the House of Commons Regulatory Reform Committee to subject it to the further scrutiny we believe it requires."

Lord Lipsey is a longstanding opponent of the government's reforms
Also giving evidence before the committees will be Labour peer Lord Lipsey who, along with Conservative MP Philip Davies, has been a longstanding opponent of the government's plans.

He said: "I, together with my colleague Philip Davies, believe this is a wholly inappropriate measure to be implemented by legislative reform order. Primary legislation which can be examined in detail by parliament is the only way forward."

Although the Levy Board will continue in its duties until the end of March, the Racing Authority has been meeting in shadow for some time.

It is being chaired by former sports minister Sir Hugh Robertson with former Coral managing director Wilf Walsh appointed as the body's senior independent director.

The remainder of the board is completed by representatives of racing's three main stakeholders – the BHA, Racecourse Association and Horsemen's Group.

Members can read the latest exclusive interviews, news analysis and comment available from 6pm daily on


I, together with my colleague Philip Davies, believe this is a wholly inappropriate measure to be implemented by legislative reform order
E.W. Terms