BHA shakes up appeals process and appoints handicapping ombudsman

Appeals against handicap marks allotted to horses will be overseen by a new independent ombudsman, the BHA announced on Wednesday.

The awarding of handicap ratings to horses is often a point of contention between the BHA and connections, with appeals made against the rating previously heard by the handicapping appeals panel.

David Cleary, the well-respected Timeform analyst and racing reporter, will be the first person to hold the role of handicapping ombudsman as part of a wider inspection of the handicapping review process. Ian Heitman will act as his deputy.

In addition to the introduction of an ombudsman, the appeal process will rely on oral evidence rather than written submissions to reach a decision, with appeals being directed to the ombudsman when direct contact between the connections and the BHA handicappers has failed to reach a satisfactory conclusion.

Should an appeal be successful, the horse’s rating will be adjusted accordingly and published as normal with the weekly handicap reassessments, while in the event of an unsuccessful challenge, the handicapper’s original decision will stand.

Richard Wayman: welcomed the establishment of an independent ombudsman

Richard Wayman, the BHA’s chief operating officer, said: “The BHA’s handicapping team aims to treat every horse fairly and is always willing to speak with connections to explain their decision. Most queries are resolved through this direct dialogue, but in a small number of cases this isn’t possible.

“In establishing an independent ombudsman, we are seeking to improve and simplify the existing appeals system, with the aim of completing reviews in a consistent and timely manner. I’m delighted that David and Ian have agreed to take on these new positions, and apply their knowledge and expertise to what can often be complicated handicapping decisions.

“I’d like to take this opportunity to thank appeal panel members for their work, in many cases over several years. I recognise that this has not always been easy, especially with panels convened at short notice and working to tight deadlines, and we are immensely grateful for their time and contribution.”

Read this next . . .

'She changed my life and I owe her a huge, huge debt' – Ouija Board dies aged 21

The Front Runner is our latest email newsletter available exclusively to Members' Club Ultimate subscribers. Chris Cook, a four-time Racing Reporter of the Year award winner, provides his take on the day's biggest stories and tips for the upcoming racing every morning from Monday to Friday