Pullein on Football: the soccer boffin's weekly dose of betting wisdom
Will early-season pacesetters in EFL create a new record or will they burn out?
This could be a record-breaking season in the EFL. Reading top the Championship with 22 points from ten games while Peterborough top League One and Newport top League Two with 25 points from 11 games.
If they accumulate points at the same rate over the rest of the 46-game season Reading will finish with 101, Peterborough and Newport with 105.
There has never been a season in which all three divisions were won by teams with at least 100 points. Only twice did two winners reach triple figures – in 2013-14 when Leicester won the Championship with 102 points and Wolves won League One with 103, and in 1998-99 when Sunderland won the Championship with 105 points and Fulham won League One with 101.
So this could be a record-breaking season. But it probably will not.
A good way to think about early-season form is to work out what it would become if it was extended over the whole season and then ask how likely that is.
I cannot tell you how many points Reading, Peterborough and Newport will end up with. What I can tell you is that on average in the EFL teams with 22 points after ten games have ended up with 79 and teams with 25 points after 11 games have ended up with 82.
When a team start a season well we might read articles explaining what they have done. Perhaps they have taken more shots or allowed opponents fewer. This does not tell us why they have improved in attack or defence, let alone whether that improvement will be maintained.
Hardly ever does anyone really know. Nearly always those who think they do are deceiving themselves and us. So a team have a new manager. He has introduced different training methods or imposed a change in formation. Did he not do this in his previous jobs? Has no one done it before? Were the results always so positive?
Matthew Syed in a book called Black Box Thinking discussed what football journalists wrote when Fabio Capello was England manager.
Capello was a disciplinarian. And England’s results initially were good. “Capello’s methods were eulogised. Finally, a coach who was willing to give the players a kick up the rear! At last, a coach who has provided discipline to those slackers! One flattering headline read: The Boss!”
Then results changed. “Almost instantly the narrative flipped. Capello is too tough! He is taking the fun out of the game! The Italian is treating our players like children! Many football journalists didn’t even notice that they had attempted to explain contradictory effects with the same underlying cause.”
Why did England’s fortunes flip-flop? “In truth, England’s results were not caused by the salient features of Capello’s actions, but by myriad factors that were not, in advance, predictable. That is why football journalists who are brilliant at explaining why teams won or lost after the event are not much better than amateurs at predicting who is going to win or lose beforehand.”
Earlier I started a sentence by saying: “If they accumulate points at the same rate over the rest of the 46-game season…” This was the beginning of a logical argument expressed in the classical form. And it exposes the limitations of logic.
Every logical argument tells us that if one statement is true another must also be true. There can be any number of intermediate steps between the first and last statements. But no matter how elaborate the reasoning is it will always begin with what logicians call an axiom. This is a statement they will accept as true even though they cannot prove it is true. We could use another word. It is an assumption.
If X happens Y must also happen, but we do not know if X will happen. Some EFL teams who set off at a blistering pace keep it up. Most do not. How many runners set off at a record-breaking pace but do not break the record?
Derby have gained fewest points in the Championship with six from ten games. Wigan are bottom of League One, albeit only on goal difference, with seven points from 11 games. Southend are bottom of League Two with two points from 11 games.
They could carry on collecting points at the same rate, and if they do Derby will finish with 28, Wigan with 29 and Southend with eight. They could slow down. Most likely they will start to gather points more quickly. On average in the EFL teams with six points after ten games have finished with 46, teams with seven points after 11 games have finished with 47 and teams with two points after 11 games have finished with 38.
No team in any EFL division have ever completed a 46-game season with fewer than 19 points – even when there were only two points for a win. So at the wrong end of the tables this could be a record-breaking season. But it probably will not.
Not got a bet365 account? Sign up today and get up to £100 in bet credits.
Up to £100 in Bet Credits for new customers at bet365. Min deposit £5. Bet Credits available for use upon settlement of bets to value of qualifying deposit. Min odds, bet and payment method exclusions apply. Returns exclude Bet Credits stake. Time limits and T&Cs apply.
CLAIM OFFER HERE
Follow us on Twitter @racingpostsport
Like us on Facebook RacingPostSport