PartialLogo
Reports10 October 2026

The man behind the Dewhurst masterplan: how John Magnier's hunch turned Darkness Falls into 3-1 Guineas favourite

Darkness Falls (right): stayed on best to win the Dewhurst
Darkness Falls (right) stays on best to win the Dewhurst from Desert CastleCredit: Edward Whitaker (racingpost.com/photos)
Google

Click here to add us to your Google preferred sources or find out more here

Many questioned the logic in dropping Darkness Falls back from a taxing 1m1f at Leopardstown to 7f for Europe’s premier colts’ two-year-old race, the Group 1 Darley Dewhurst Stakes.

Surely a juvenile with such abundant stamina who had not raced at less than a mile in his career would not have the requisite pace to defeat Desert Castle, winner of the Champagne Stakes, and Coventry Stakes scorer Great Barrier Reef?

Yet Aidan O’Brien had been convinced of its possibility by John Magnier, the Coolmore supremo, who had dropped the idea of the plan to the trainer. That, and that alone, it seems, was enough to overlook any other considerations.

“It was a big call to come here, to bring a horse back from nine furlongs to the Dewhurst,” O’Brien said. “We thought it would be hard coming back to seven furlongs and it was John’s idea.

“No-one is more expert in the world of breeding horses, watching horses and being around horses than him. We’re so lucky to have him around for that input and we have that kind of relationship where he says what he thinks but he does that when it matters.

“When he said it to me I thought that would make the horse ultra-exciting if he was able to do it, and that’s what he is.”

The Betfred 2,000 Guineas had initiated the thinking behind Darkness Falls coming to Newmarket for the Dewhurst. Track experience for next year would be one advantage gained from it, as would an understanding of whether the colt would have the pace for a contest O’Brien likens to a sprint due to where it falls in a three-year-old’s development.


Analysis

Forget the 7-2 for the Guineas - there's a smarter way to back Darkness Falls three-year-old campaign 


Inevitably, the challenge of the Triple Crown was put to O’Brien. No horse since Nijinsky in 1970 has won the 2,000 Guineas, Derby and St Leger in the same season. One has come close, Camelot, who was denied by Encke in the final leg in 2012.

“The total test of the thoroughbred,” was how O’Brien described the Triple Crown, which has been coveted by Magnier for as long as he has been in racing. Michael Tabor, Derrick Smith and Georg von Opel are unlikely to need too much persuasion to attempt to win it next year.

Aidan O'Brien leans in to speak to Ryan Moore after the Dewhurst
Aidan O'Brien leans in to speak to Ryan Moore after the DewhurstCredit: Edward Whitaker (racingpost.com/photos)

O’Brien said: “He’s a lovely, classy horse. He has that much class to do anything and he’s very exciting. We’ll start in the Guineas and then we’ll see what happens after that.

“We wanted to see if he could be a Guineas horse and even if he just showed up well today then we knew he would be. He’s very uncomplicated and classy, and Ryan [Moore] said he had plenty left at the end as well. We can sleep well over the winter with him.”

Prices for the Triple Crown varied with bookmakers. Paddy Power rated Darkness Falls a 12-1 chance, Coral went 14-1 and William Hill priced him at 25-1.

The first leg will be next year’s 2,000 Guineas, for which the Dewhurst first and second reversed places in the market. Paddy Power cut Darkness Falls to 3-1 favourite (from 16) while runner-up Desert Castle was eased to 5-1 (from 7-2) for next season’s Classic.

Darkness Falls and Desert Castle fight out the Dewhurst finish
Darkness Falls and Desert Castle fight out the Dewhurst finishCredit: Edward Whitaker (racingpost.com/photos)

Godolphin trainer Charlie Appleby may have hoped to have ended the Future Champions meeting with two Classic favourites following Musical Times’s success in the Fillies’ Mile on Friday, but had to settle for second best with Desert Castle.

He said: “William [Buick] said he expected to be taking him back at the three [furlong marker] but instead he was asking him. He was up against a horse who had already seen out nine furlongs, so he wasn't going to stop, but I was pleased with our horse. He got to the winner but he couldn't get past.

“He was very raw on his first run and he still showed that at Donny, but he has come forward in that sense and is mentally growing up. I always felt he was going to be next year's horse and he still has a lot more maturing to do physically. We'll put him away now for the winter and look towards the Guineas.

"We'll have a rematch in the spring and see who's the best."

Betfred 2,000 Guineas (Newmarket, May 1, 2027)
William Hill: 7-2 Darkness Falls, 4 Desert Castle, 12 Folsom Blues, 16 Monogram, 20 Abraham Lincoln, Great Barrier Reef, 25 bar.

Betfred Derby (Epsom, June 5, 2027)
Coral: 4 Darkness Falls, 16 Abraham Lincoln, Haffner, Noble Exhibit, 20 Bin Jahwar, 25 Drumbeat, Monogram, Wall Street, 33 bar.


Read more:

'I didn't know an apprentice could ride like that' – Alphonse Le Grande becomes second dual Cesarewitch winner under 19-year-old jockey 

Forget the 7-2 for the Guineas - there's a smarter way to back Darkness Falls three-year-old campaign 

‘It's a huge thing for the breed’ - Dewhurst hero Darkness Falls sparks talk of following sire Camelot down Triple Crown trail 

'They've done their best to get her beat but couldn't' - William Buick relieved after Musical Times overcomes adversity in Fillies' Mile 


Looking for free bets? Racing Post have got the best offers, all in one place. Visit racingpost.com/freebets to find out more.


author image
Deputy industry editor

Published on inReports

Last updated

iconCopy
Google

Click here to add us to your Google preferred sources or find out more here