So sad that a horse like Mr Vango can't run in the Grand National - but muzzling Willie Mullins isn't the solution
Julian Muscat calls for Aintree to adopt the Kentucky Derby's policy in determining the final field

It has been instructive to follow the debate about whether to recalibrate the make-up of the Grand National field. The tried-and-trusted formula of allowing the highest-rated horses to face the starter, as they will on Saturday, is under scrutiny. Romance is in short supply, unlike the preponderance of horses trained in Ireland – and by Willie Mullins in particular.
This has spawned some spurious suggestions, not least that there should be a limit on the number of horses each trainer can saddle. Even if that limit was set at four, as has been mooted, there would be perhaps a small handful of extra places each year – and the chances are that other horses trained in Ireland would be the main beneficiaries anyway.
Ireland’s dominance of the jumping scene should have no bearing on how the Grand National line-up might change for the better. In racing, periods of dominance tend to promote thinly veiled efforts to curb that dominance in the name of variety or diversity.
Read the full story
Read award-winning journalism from the best writers in racing, with exclusive news, interviews, columns, investigations, stable tours and subscriber-only emails.
Subscribe to unlock
- Racing Post digital newspaper (worth over £100 per month)
- Award-winning journalism from the best writers in racing
- Expert tips from the likes of Tom Segal and Paul Kealy
- Replays and results analysis from all UK and Irish racecourses
- Form study tools including the Pro Card and Horse Tracker
- Extensive archive of statistics covering horses, trainers, jockeys, owners, pedigree and sales data
Already a subscriber?Log in
Published on inJulian Muscat
Last updated
- Royal Ascot inspires enterprise from across the world - yet it's a traditional British owner-breeder who has made the boldest move of all
- Classic crop looks seriously strong - and one of them stands tall as racing's next likely superstar
- Delacroix or The Lion In Winter? Coolmore face tough choice when giving Ryan Moore the leg up at Epsom
- Could the extraordinary story of Galileo and Epsom have one last surprise chapter in it? Lingfield trial suggests it might
- Godolphin's triumphant Classic weekend proves that the phoenix has truly risen from the ashes of the Al Zarooni scandal
- Royal Ascot inspires enterprise from across the world - yet it's a traditional British owner-breeder who has made the boldest move of all
- Classic crop looks seriously strong - and one of them stands tall as racing's next likely superstar
- Delacroix or The Lion In Winter? Coolmore face tough choice when giving Ryan Moore the leg up at Epsom
- Could the extraordinary story of Galileo and Epsom have one last surprise chapter in it? Lingfield trial suggests it might
- Godolphin's triumphant Classic weekend proves that the phoenix has truly risen from the ashes of the Al Zarooni scandal