PartialLogo
News

Hearing into controversy over Elliott picture under way at undisclosed venue

Gordon Elliott. Cullentra House Stables.Photo: Patrick McCann 27.02.2018
Gordon Elliott: hearing into dead horse picture got underway this morningCredit: Patrick McCann (racingpost.com/photos)

The Irish Horseracing Regulatory Board's referrals hearing that will decide Gordon Elliott's fate following the emergence of a picture of the three-time Grand National-winning trainer sitting astride a dead horse is under way at an undisclosed location.

On Thursday, the IHRB was unwilling to disclose where the parties would be convening, but it did confirm that the hearing would be getting underway at 9.30 this morning. Various media gathered at its headquarters on the Curragh but there was no sign of the relevant parties.

After a week of controversy and speculation, the initiation of the hearing moves Elliott another step closer to learning the extent to which the damaging image is going to cost him professionally.

It seems unlikely that the trainer will saddle runners at the Cheltenham Festival, with the BHA having the power under its rules to extend the temporary block on Elliott entries regardless of the outcome of the case.

It is unclear whether the referrals panel will deliver a verdict today, but should the Cheltenham Gold Cup and three-time Grand National-winning trainer have his licence suspended, it is understood that contingency plans for the immediate future of his string are under consideration at his Cullentra House base. Elliott would have seven days to appeal against any potential penalty.

Gordon Elliott: sent out a double at Downpatrick on Friday
Gordon Elliott: one of the most dominant forces at the Cheltenham FestivalCredit: Patrick McCann (racingpost.com/photos)

A suspension barring Elliott from having any runners in Britain was imposed by the BHA on Monday and remains in place until the conclusion of the IHRB case, whether that today or at a later date. That would also apply were Elliott to appeal against any disciplinary action.

James Given, the BHA’s director of equine health and welfare, said on Wednesday the BHA’s intention “isn't to stop horses running, we want to see the best horses run at Cheltenham", and that it would consider what action is best to allow that following the IHRB decision.

However, the regulator, which has labelled the photo of Elliott sitting on Morgan with his phone in one hand and holding two fingers up on his other hand in a 'peace' or 'victory' sign as "totally unacceptable", has the ability to refuse entries from any trainer. That would permit it to maintain a suspension on Elliott having runners if it chose to do so even if his licence is not removed by the IHRB.

Gordon Elliott: pointing three runners at the €50,000 handicap chase at Leopardstown
Gordon Elliott: not permitted to have runners in Britain while IHRB investigation is ongoingCredit: Patrick McCann

If Elliott receives a suspension or disqualification from the Irish authorities, that would be reciprocated by the BHA.

Suggestions had been made that Davy Russell, who has been an integral part of some of Elliott's biggest successes, could take a hands-on role in the training of the string, but the sidelined rider moved to quash such rumours and emphasised that a return to the saddle is at the forefront of his mind.

"I don't know anything about it and it's totally unfounded," Russell told the Irish Independent about the speculation. "I haven't been approached in any way, shape or form, I haven't been approached by the Turf Club or by Gordon or by anyone. The only job I have is that I speak to a lot of owners and I ride horses and that's my main priority."

He added: "I have to get back, I've no other choice, that's my job. I'm a jockey and I need to continue being a jockey, that's all I know. I'm not going training horses, if that was the case then it’d be something that I’d be concentrating on the day I got the fall."

The IHRB also confirmed to the Racing Post on Thursday afternoon that no referral date has been set for the investigation into the unsettling video of Cheltenham Festival-winning amateur jockey Rob James.


Key questions and answers for Friday's hearing

Who will be on the panel?

Details of the individuals sitting on the referrals panel will not be disclosed prior to the hearing, in line with IHRB protocols. A spokesperson said: "It is not standard practice for us to confirm the delegation of the referrals or appeals body in advance of a hearing."

Under which regulation will Elliott be charged?

The IHRB does not release such information in advance of a case but it has been suggested that the most applicable regulation could be rule 272, which relates to preserving the good reputation of horseracing.

A fine or suspension could be implemented under this regulation, but the rule through which any charge is addressed will only be determined once the panel establishes the facts of the case.

The IHRB rule book states sanctions are possible for an individual who "whether verbally or by conduct or behaviour, acts in a manner which is prejudicial to the integrity, proper conduct or good reputation of horseracing [whether or not such behaviour or conduct, verbal or otherwise is associated directly with horseracing]."

The IHRB referrals panel will hear the evidence from all sides in any referral case, consider the evidence put before it and deliberate its decision, with the potential for a 14-day period before a suspension takes effect. An outcome can be appealed against within the following seven days.

Determining the sort of sanctions that could be imposed by the IHRB is difficult, but the BHA has the power to refuse entries in Britain from any individual it wishes – regardless of the referral's outcome.

Will the outcome of the hearing be made public on Friday?

An IHRB spokesperson said earlier this week the time of year or interest in other racing jurisdictions would not prevent the regulator from following due process.

Although the cases vary significantly in nature, details of the recent Viking Hoard saga involving Charles Byrnes were revealed to the public 12 days after the referral date and following the subsequent appeal there was a nine-day gap before the final judgement was published.

"The decision to reserve or give a judgement on the day of a hearing is at the discretion of the panel that hears a case," said an IHRB spokesperson.

Is the hearing open to the public or media?

The referral will take place behind closed doors and no members of the media will be permitted to attend. The referral is set to take place in person but the IHRB would not confirm where it will be held.

The regulator typically announces the outcomes of such proceedings through its official Twitter feed. The Racing Post's digital platforms will provide live coverage of the result as soon as it is revealed.


More on the Gordon Elliott story:

BHA welfare chief: it is our intention to get the best horses to Cheltenham

Noel Moran: rumours our horses have left Gordon Elliott are totally untrue

Gordon Elliott: 'I will spend my life paying for indefensible moment of madness'

Gordon Elliott barred from having runners in Britain while image inquiry goes on

Leading owners Gigginstown stand by Gordon Elliott after 'unacceptable' photo

Comment: the tragedy of these images is they have given cause to doubt racing's sincerity (Members' Club)

Comment: majority of horse people have been done a disservice by shocking images (Members' Club)


Members can click here to download the digital newspaper every evening from 9pm. Not a member? Click here to sign up and enjoy the digital newspaper every day.


Mark BoylanReporter
Peter ScargillDeputy industry editor

Published on 4 March 2021inNews

Last updated 17:46, 5 March 2021

iconCopy